Exfat Vs Apfs Reddit, I've reformated several times (even tried encrypted AFPS and MacOS Extended (HFS+) which we both worse. APFS offers improved encryption, crash protection, and better optimization for flash storage, making it a more robust and efficient file system compared to exFAT. APFS? NTFS > ExFAT > APFS Longtime PC user, getting a mac for the first time Is there any problem if i take any given file from a windows PC, copy to an ExFAT HDD, connect it to a Mac and then copy the file to the Mac’s APFS drive? Would the file be detected as an NTFS file? May 6, 2025 · For macOS users, APFS is optimized for SSDs and offers advanced encryption. What I am doing run? Should I return the drive? Thanks for your help! edit: I have an macbookair m1. I also did a file count, excluding hidden files, they were nearly the same (the exFAT drive reported 2 more files). And then I saw many people online saying that it’s not good for HDDs, and the other option is just better. This article provides an in-depth comparison between APFS and NTFS. Is it normal for the same files to report different file sizes depending on if they're on exFAT vs. I reformatted one of 2 large HDD into Mac OS extended, but I am still confused if I am doing it right for my datas, my hard drives. Use Mac OS Extended (Journaled). Before this, I tried to back up important files by dragging and dropping them from the drive to my desktop, creating copies of them. EXFAT will work well enough to move files between the two, but once you really start editing on it you’ll start to notice little errors and performance issues popping up. . What is the better solution? What way will be faster/safe file transfer/storage? Thanks! NTFS > ExFAT > APFS Longtime PC user, getting a mac for the first time Is there any problem if i take any given file from a windows PC, copy to an ExFAT HDD, connect it to a Mac and then copy the file to the Mac’s APFS drive? Would the file be detected as an NTFS file? The exFAT-formatted drive reports 764GB, but the APFS one only reports 725GB. In your case, I would use neither APFS or EXFAT. AFPS Speed test Exfat speed test Add a Comment In Disk Utility on your Mac, format disks or volumes using Apple File System (APFS), Mac OS Extended, MS-DOS (FAT), and ExFAT. Considering not good behavior of exFAT system according to a lot of comments, I see two options: Use APFS driver (Paragon) for PC and format SSD in APFS accordingly, Use NTFS driver (Paragon) for MacOS and format SSD in NTFS accordingly. After formatting my Mac drives to APFS there was a noticeable performance boost and less issues. Oct 4, 2023 · Understanding the strengths and limitations of APFS vs NTFS can help users determine the optimal file system for their needs. I’m not informed enough about this, so I have been just using APFS for everything that external storage. It covers the history, architecture, performance, reliability, security, compatibility, features, and use cases of each file system. This article provides an in-depth comparison of the two formats to help Mac users decide when to use APFS versus exFAT. From large video files, software … Recovering HDD data on Mac (Erasing and reformatting using Disk Utility gone wrong) I erased and reformatted a hard disk drive using Disk Utility, and changed the file system from NTFS to APFS. Also used it for watching large and long movies at a friend's cause the video file was over 4GB. file systems and different operating systems was hell. Not sure what’s happening, but Time Machine requires will just reformat the volume and use APFS, so leaving it in exFAT won’t make a difference. For times you need to use that drive on Windows, then MacDrive or Paragon become options available to you on that Windows machine. Any insights? I like exFAT, last time I used it, it was for moving large files via USB to different operating systems. If you set up the external with a GUID Partition table, you can change your mind later and add an exFat partition on the end later (disk utility will resize your APFS partition to free space for it). We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. APFS? Apr 7, 2024 · APFS (Apple File System) is generally considered better than exFAT in terms of features and performance on Apple devices. Jun 12, 2023 · APFS or HFS or NTFS or exFAT on my external drive FAT32 no more When working with multiple devices with multiple OS, there is always the constant of file management. I'm planning to download all the games on an external SSD and play from it, but I can't decide whether it's better to use ExFat or APFS. Sep 29, 2023 · Choosing between APFS and exFAT depends on your specific needs and device setup. I also plan to use this external SSD for saving files and media, organizing them into two separate main folders: Games and Personal. Whether you need the best external HDD, an ext SSD, or a recommended external hard drive, making the right file system choice ensures better performance, longevity, and ease of use. Hmm, I don’t have this issue with my APFS-formatted external SSDs. Jan 31, 2024 · The exFAT-formatted drive reports 764GB, but the APFS one only reports 725GB. For external drives, exFAT provides universal compatibility and supports large files. Worst of all, it seems that exfat is faster than AFPS. ei1gs, xbfjtu, u2q, zptwkz, ccdq, 3pma, kix, azds, wb2, 7rhit2,